With all the talk of holiday stress and the economic meltdown, I wanted do a little something different when it came to Christmas cookies for my hen party gift exchange last week. Inspired by this artist, I decided that if I couldn’t bring actual happy pills to the party, I could at least make my cookies look like them:

Since Zoloft is sort of non-descript, I went with its cartoon mascot instead:

I also made some non-specific pill cookies that were frosted a solid color on one end with sprinkles on the other end (so they looked like capsules).
My attempt at antacid cookies (made multi-colored by adding food coloring to this recipe) was passable but the “T” (for Tums) stamped in them didn’t hold up during baking. The Xanax cookies were a complete flop in all respects but taste since I made them too small to handle any writing. Hence, no photos of these.
Despite the above-noted mishaps, the cookies produced a big laugh when they were unveiled and were absolutely worth the time.
Note: Lest you imagine our household with candy dishes of pills on every end table, Google Images — not a personal stash — was my visual reference for this project.
The streets were icy on baking day, and between that and the holiday rush I had absolutely no desire to go to the store to get the proper tools. A glass and a plastic cup (squeezed just so) served as cookie cutters, and I did the cut-out in the Valium cookies with a paring knife.
The frosting is a little sloppy because (a) it’s powdered sugar frosting, and (b) I was using a zip-top bag with a hole cut in it since I don’t have a proper pastry bag or tips. I had so much fun doing this that I may invest in some decorating equipment. The possiblities are endless.


